Americans arrested for taking kids out of Haiti

This was all over the news yesterday, so it may have been resolved, but if you haven’t seen it elsewhere here is the story from Reuters:

Haitian police have arrested 10 U.S. citizens caught trying to take 33 children out of the earthquake-stricken country in a suspected illicit adoption scheme, authorities said on Saturday.

The five men and five women were in custody in the capital, Port-au-Prince after their arrests on Friday night. There are fears that traffickers could try to exploit the chaos and turmoil following Haiti’s January 12 earthquake quake to engage in illegal adoptions.

One of the suspects, who says she is leader of an Idaho-based charity called New Life Children’s Refuge, denied they had done anything wrong.

The suspects were detained at Malpasse, Haiti’s main border crossing with the Dominican Republic, after Haitian police conducted a routine search of their vehicle.

Authorities said the Americans had no documents to prove they had cleared the adoption of the 33 children — aged 2 months to 12 years — through any embassy and no papers showing they were made orphans by the quake in the impoverished Caribbean country.

“This is totally illegal,” said Yves Cristalin, Haiti’s social affairs minister. “No children can leave Haiti without proper authorization and these people did not have that authorization.”

Further down in the story is more news I hadn’t heard.

In addition to outright trafficking in children, authorities have voiced fears since the quake that legitimate aid groups may have flown earthquake orphans out of the country for adoption before efforts to find their parents had been exhausted.

As a result, the Haitian government halted many types of adoptions earlier this month.

Limon: Give Haitian “victims” priority, bring in the family

That is the gist of the opinion piece published today in USA Today.  The author is Lavinia Limon head honcho of the US Committee for Refugees and Immigrants (USCRI). 

Let Haitians with relatives in the USA immigrate here ASAP.

The horrific disaster in Haiti compels us to act in every way possible to reduce suffering and save lives. I salute everyone working on the ground in dreadful conditions to provide medical assistance, food, water and shelter. Although the relief is agonizingly slow, there’s progress, and it will accelerate.

What else can we do?

We can help the approximately 50,000 Haitians who’ve already gotten U.S. government approval to come to this country because they have a close relative (spouse, child, parent or sibling) who’s a U.S. citizen or legal permanent resident.

[….]

But we shouldn’t stop there. Other Haitians who also have family in the U.S. should be allowed to join their relatives for humanitarian reasons. They could work and send money home to help rebuild Haiti.

Readers should know that family reunification is a big part of the refugee resettlement business.  Agencies like USCRI (one of the Top Ten, now nine, federal refugee contractors*) through its affiliates resettle refugees in your town and then they are paid by the government to fill out paperwork to bring extended family members.  That is an important part of their income and how they change your community over time.  They then are paid by the head to resettle the new refugees (and as we learned this week that funding has increased by 100%).

You may recall that the family reunification program has been suspended for “refugees” coming from some areas of the world (most notably Africa) because the State Department discovered that about 80% of the applications were fraudulent.  The anchor refugee was likely not related to those he or she was applying to bring to the US.

As of this writing, there is one comment to the opinion piece at USA Today, it is from Christopher Coen at Friends of Refugees (we told you about Mr. Coen’s work here).

The message to help Haitians is a good one. Too bad it comes from someone who heads an organization, the USCRI, that has severely neglected refugees in this country for years. Just in the past 2 years newspapers around the country have reported about USCRI refugees who have been dropped off in filthy, decrepit, and roach & rodent-infested apartments and left to fend for themselves with little assistance from USCRI’s network of refugee offices. A USCRI affiliate in Connecticut even lost it’s government contract to resettle refugees so bad was the neglect.

Ms. Limon would be better off using her time to adequately care for the refugees her organization has already been entrusted with, rather than advocate for even more refugees to neglect.

Christopher Coen
director
Friends of Refugees

The Connecticut reference involves a story we covered extensively (here is just one link to get you started) involving an USCRI affiliate in Waterbury, CT.  Recently we have chronicled the on-going problems in Bowling Green, KY (and here), that is also an USCRI affiliate involved in Bowling Green.  Complaints against USCRI have been made in other states as well (Ohio, Vermont, Missouri and New York for starters).

*For readers who are completely new to the refugee program there are ten (nine as of this week) volags (supposedly voluntary agencies) that contract with the US State Department to resettle refugees.  They then have affiliates in “welcoming” cities who receive their government funding as a pass-through from the ‘mother agencies’ which are responsible for making sure their affiliates use the taxpayers’ money properly and adequately care for the refugees (find them apartments, jobs and get them signed up for welfare) they have been assigned.   Review by the State Department is sporadic until an agency has been brought to the publics’ attention through the media.

Haitian immigrants fact sheet from Center for Immigration Studies

Please visit CIS for all sorts of handy facts about how many Haitians are in the US and what their status is in terms of citizenship, education, welfare use and so on.  Here are just a few of the facts, compiled by Steven Camarota, to pique your interest:

Of the 546,000 Haitians in the US in 2008 (assuming the census was correct):

The top states of Haitian immigrant settlement are Florida (251,963; 46%), New York (135,836; 25%) New Jersey (43,316; 8%), Massachusetts (36,779; 7%), Georgia (13,287; 2%), and Maryland (11,266; 2%).

[….]

When it extended Temporary Protected Status to Haitians, the Department of Homeland Security estimated 100,000 to 200,000 people could be eligible. While most are illegal immigrants, this estimate also includes those on temporary visas such as tourists, foreign students, and guest workers who will not have to go home.

Read it all!

Haitians not “refugees” but “evacuees” says NC refugee coordinator

The issue of what status the Haitians would have must have been brewing in an already overloaded North Carolina refugee program for the question to have come up. 

We’ve had extensive coverage of the turmoil in Greensboro recently with refugees living in substandard housing, church leaders angry with resettlement agencies and with refugees trying to figure out how to get out of Greensboro and North Carolina where the unemployment rate is one of the top ten highest in the nation.

This is from Star News:

North Carolina has been resettling increasing numbers of refugees, from about 1,200 in 2006 to nearly 2,300 in 2008, the most recent year for which statistics are available.

It’s the 10th-largest state for resettling refugees, accepting about four percent of the national total, according to Marlene Myers, the state refugee coordinator.

Someone must have been asking if NC was bringing more refugees—the Haitians.

Myers said that it was not yet determined how many Haitians might come to North Carolina, or where in the state they might go. But they would be classified as “evacuees,” not refugees, so a different agency in the N.C. Division of Social Services would be in charge of placing them. Since Interfaith Refugee Ministry deals with political refugees intending to settle permanently in the U.S., it will not be dealing with Haitian refugees.

Refugee or evacuee doesn’t really matter—either one is cared for by the taxpayers.  The only difference, as Myers makes clear, is it will just be different agencies spending your money.

Haitian refugee news roundup

I am deluged with news about Haitian refugees, so the best I can do today is list a bunch of stories that you should see.  These have been piling up in my in-box, thanks to readers for sending them.

Haitians begin arriving in Tampa:

A planeload of Haitians has just landed at Tampa International Airport.

The C-130 military aircraft landed about 9:15 p.m. It is carrying 34 people, half of them injured and needing medical attention.

Fifteen of the injured are Haitians; two are members of the U.S. military. Most of the remaining passengers are family members.

Airport, medical and relief agency officials have been on alert for days for the possibility Hatians needing help would begin arriving in the Bay area. Most of the injured have gone to South Florida, but those medical facilities are beginning to reach capacity.

I guess the big question the folks in Tampa are asking is, will they go back to Haiti after their medical treatment.

A couple of readers sent me this Washington Post story about how Haitian refugees will be coming to the US at some point.  I don’t know what it says because the darned article has frozen my computer 3 times when I tried to read it!  I think its their pop-up ad.  Maybe you will have better luck.  I’ve been given these few lines from the story:

Among Haitians and their U.S. relatives, Limon [that would be Lavinia, whoop de do, Limon of the US Committee for Refugees and Immigrants] predicted, pressure on U.S. immigration policy will escalate in the coming weeks and months. “You need a boat, a captain, money. Nobody has that,” she said. “But in two weeks, four weeks, six weeks, they will.”

A Pennsylvania town offers an empty school to house refugees from Haiti thinking it will bring an economic boom to their county. Good luck with that idea.

Aid agencies blasted.  This is a story that was all over the place a few days ago.  The link I’ve given you is just one of many on the topic.

A leading British medical journal [Lancet] says many international aid groups in Haiti are more concerned with self-promotion than helping earthquake survivors.

Here is a blog post from before the earthquake that says aid workers sexually abuse Haitians.

Gallup reports results similar to Rasmussen. Most Americans don’t want more Haitian refugees.

PRINCETON, N.J., Jan. 26 (UPI) — Most Americans oppose allowing more Haitian refugees into the United States in the wake of the devastating Jan. 12 earthquake, a Gallup poll indicates.

In a survey released Tuesday, Gallup said the immigration issue produces a sharp political divide, with 57 percent of Democrats in favor of allowing more immigrants, while 57 percent of independents and 67 percent of Republicans are opposed.

More later.