CNN gets in on the Rohingya story today

Update Jan. 17th:   The story is growing like a cancer.

While I was out today, I happened to notice a TV tuned to CNN with a trailer that said something like ‘Thailand denies whipping refugees on beach.’   Here is the story CNN has reported today on the alleged mistreatment by the Thai military of Rohingya Muslims from Myanmar and Bangladesh arriving illegally in Thailand.

This is what a representative of Refugees International told CNN:

“The Thai government is taking highly vulnerable people and risking their lives for political gain,” says Refugee International’s Sean Garcia says.

“It should be engaging the Burmese government on improving conditions at home for the Rohingya if it wants to stem these flows.

I don’t get it, Mr. Garcia, what political gain is Thailand getting out of this?  And, what the heck is “engaging the Burmese government”.     I hate it when these yakkers tell other people (or countries) to start “engaging!”   Engaging how?   More talking?   

And, I noticed too that CNN never mentions that the Thai government is afraid this latest huge influx of Rohingya men (they have not brought women and children) have actually come to Thailand to join the Islamic insurgency in the south of that country.  Oh no, it’s all about the immigrants, never about a country protecting its sovereignty or the safety of its citizens.

I don’t mean to suggest that Thailand shouldn’t treat the Rohingya humanely, they should.    Detain them, treat them well, and deport them back to where they came from.    But, I can just see it coming….actually I hear the drumbeats.

The US will have to airlift them to a town near you, just as the Maltese boat people are being brought to America or the Iraqis by the tens of thousands.

For more on the Rohingya, see our category here, including all of our recent posts on the Rohingya boat men.

Rohingya boat men arrive in NY Times “Luxury Destination of the Year”

Things are really heating up  in the waters off Thailand.   We have been reporting about increased numbers of Burmese Muslim men—Rohingya—trying to reach Thailand by boat and being intercepted by the Thai Navy, see my post just yesterday.

Now, according to Phuket Wan,  Refugees International and Amnesty International are weighing in on the case and blasting the Thai government for mistreating  the Rohingya boat men.

AMNESTY International has released a report that accuses the Thai military of ”systematic” torture of suspected insurgents in the South.

The BBC says the report, citing testimony from victims, ”said troops had beaten and kicked detainees, given them electric shocks, near-suffocated them and sexually abused them.

”In one case, it said, three rubber farmers were detained. One was beaten until he died, the other two were brutally tortured by soldiers who wanted them to admit to being insurgents.”

This follows the report a day earlier from Washington-based Refugees International, calling on the Thai Government to ”instruct its Army to desist from its new and troubling policy of pushing refugees and migrants intercepted on boats back out to sea.”

For the Thai government’s side they maintain that the Rohingya are arriving to join the jihad on-going in southern Thailand.     In light of the location in which all this is occuring the government of Thailand needs to come up with a better plan for handling illegal aliens.   It’s kind of stupid of them to be allegedly violating human rights in plain view of New York tourists sunning at  “The Luxury Destination of the Year” , or anywhere for that matter.

This human drama is being played out on the same Andaman stretch that was this week labeled ”The Luxury Destination of the Year” by the New York Times Travel Section.

My suggestion to the Thai government:  Intercept the boats, have a nice detention center where the detainees are well cared for and as soon as possible deport them back to where they came from.   In the long run it would be much cheaper even if you have to do it over and over again.

Unfortunately the push is now on, the “durable solution” drums are beating, to resettle Rohingya in the west and charges of such abuses will only help make Refugee International’s case that the Rohingya need to be living in your town.  Most recently the UK and Canada have taken Rohingya.

See our ‘Rohingya Reports’ category here for more.

Rohingya said to be left at sea by Thai Army

This seems pretty incredible to me, but here is the story.  We have written on several recent occasions that Rohingya Muslims from Myanmar (formerly Burma) and Bangladesh have been trying to get to Thailand by the hundreds in the last few months.  The boat people (really boat “men”) are most often apprehended by the Thai Navy.  Now comes news (rumor?) that the Thai Army is taking custody of them and literally disposing of the problem.

BANGKOK, Jan 12 – Thailand’s army is secretly detaining boatpeople on an island in the Andaman Sea, before towing them into international waters and abandoning them with only paddles, sources involved in the process said.

The army officially denies holding any Rohingya – Muslims who come from the border areas of Myanmar and Bangladesh – who sail for Southeast Asia at this time of year by the hundreds.

But Ranong provincial governor Wanchart Wongchaichana said all Rohingya who arrive in the area are turned over to the army.

The army denies the charges:

The sources include officers who were present at Rohingya handovers to the army.

However, Colonel Manat denied having Rohingya in custody. “If I see Rohingya, I will arrest them and hand them to the police. The army does not have Rohingya,” he said, before switching off his mobile phone.

The Rohingya are increasingly on the world’s radar.

The fate of the Rohingya is increasingly being discussed in regional diplomatic circles, amid reports of them also reaching Indonesia, Malaysia, and India’s Andaman and Nicobar Islands.

The subject is expected to be raised at next month’s Asean summit in Thailand.

Human rights group are angry, but the Thai government fears the Rohingya will join the Muslim insurgency if steps aren’t taken to protect Thailand from their illegal entry.

Chris Lewa, a Bangkok-based social worker who is seeking better treatment for the Rohingya boatpeople.

She said that brokers in Bangladesh, Myanmar and Malaysia were encouraging desperate Rohingya to make the dangerous boat journey to Thailand despite the possibility that they could be turned back.

Even if the unwelcome migration does present a security threat, as the army claims, the way the Rohingya are treated may contravene international law, Lewa said.

Thai authorities have long been concerned about the arrival of large numbers of Rohingya, fearing some of them may head south to join the long-running Muslim insurgency.

In March last year, then prime minister Samak Sundaravej asked the navy to find a suitable island on which to detain the Rohingya.

But the idea of holding them in such a facility met outcry from human rights advocates and was supposedly shelved.

At the time, military chief Supreme Commander General Boonsrang Niumpradit said of the Rohingya sneaking in to Thailand: “The graph is rising and it is worrying, and we have to try to solve the problem.”

Rohingya usually arrive in Thailand from November to April, while seas are at their calmest.

According to official figures, in 2005-2006, 1,225 arrived in Thailand; in 2006-2007, there were 2,763. In 2007-2008, there were 4,886. From Nov 26 to Dec 25 last year, 659 Rohingya were detained in eight separate incidents.

For more on the Rohingya go to our category “Rohingya Reports” here.   Rohingya are being resettled in the west and pressure is building for the US to take them too.

Refugees International report: Resettle Rohingya in US

One of the recommendations from a Refugees International Field Report  is for the US to send more financial aid to the Burmese Muslim Rohingya displaced people and to work to resettle them in the US.  To date, we have not officially begun resettling Rohingya.

The summary of the December 19th report tells us what we already know from recent news accounts.  From RI:

With few options available to the Rohingya in Bangladesh, more and more people are risking their lives to travel to Malaysia to seek livelihood opportunities. The number of Rohingya boat people [Editor: more accurately boat men. Women and children have not been found in the boats.]  originating from inside Burma and from Bangladesh is increasing, despite the dangers posed by dishonest brokers, substandard boats, and the Thai navy. Although many have lost their lives at sea or were caught and detained by Burmese authorities, many more continue to reach Malaysia. In all, an estimated one million Rohingya now live in Bangladesh, Thailand, Malaysia, the Middle East, and farther afield.

But, follow the link to the PDF report and note the recommendations including one to resettle Rohingya.

The UN and donor governments, particularly the US, should integrate the Rohingya into programs that address Burmese displacement, including resettlement.

The UK and Canada have recently begun resettlement.    For more on Rohingya see our category ‘Rohingya Reports’ here.

Refugees International is a lobbying arm of the refugee industry and we wrote previously that they have advocated that the Obama administration allow over 100,000 Iraqis to enter the US this fiscal year.

Canada taking greater number of Rohingya Muslims and demand assimilation

Other than Time magazine in 2002,  I haven’t even seen the word Rohingya in any American mainstream media story.  The article in Time linked the Rohingya to Al Qaeda. (See my first post from a year ago on the Rohingya with the link to Time here.)

So far the US has not officially accepted the Burmese Rohingya Muslims even while the UN is working mighty hard to open up their resettlement to Canada, Europe, and Australia.    Canada is now expecting to take 5000 in the next few years!

From the Calgary Herald:

She (a Rohingya refugee interviewed for this article) is part of a group of 54 refugees from Burma — including 36 children and 14 women — who have landed recently in Quebec thanks to a federal refugee program. They are among the first group of some 5,000 Rohingya people, a Muslim ethnic minority from western Burma’s Arakan state, who will be coming to Canada in the next few years.

I’m happy that these Rohingya Muslim women were able to get rid of abusive husbands.   By the way, the camps in which they lived are reported to be terrorist recruitment centers (see Time link).   I guess beating one’s wife goes right along with Islamic terrorism.

“The time spent with my husband was the worst,” Tamira, 25, tells the translator Ashraful in a mix of Bengali and Rohingyalish language.

She explains that her husband beat her but she stops short of giving details. “It’s a long story. It will hurt and I will cry if I tell it,” she says.

But Tamira and Senoyra are grateful to be in Canada now, far away from the dangerous conditions of the camps and their former husbands.

Maybe it will work out for Canada if they stick to the policy mentioned here.  Frankly I was amazed that an immigration official would tell these women—assimilate or no one else in your family comes to Canada.  Why aren’t we doing that in the US?  Actually I posted on a US report just a few weeks ago that said we must Americanize immigrants or we will be in deep trouble.  Back to the Calgary Herald story:

When Immigration and Citizenship minister Jason Kenney paid a courtesy visit to the Burmese refugees in Quebec City recently he was assailed with questions. “Can the rest of my family come here?” “What do I have to do?”

The translator was relaying their concerns to the minister who refused to make any public commitment. “We have a reunification program and you will be in a good position to help your family if you settle here and integrate well into your new country,” Kenney told them. He stressed that learning one or both official languages and finding a job will be crucial to help them eventually sponsor their family to come to Canada.

I’ve written 40 previous posts on the Rohingya over the last 12 months, so if you are interested go to our category Rohingya Reports and learn more.