Rohingya appeal to Amnesty International to intercede with UNHCR

The Rohingya are Burmese Muslims who are spreading out throughout Bangladesh, Malaysia, Thailand and even Pakistan.  They want to be resettled in the West.  Canada has taken some already and maybe we have too, but no one is saying.

Although this plea from Rohingya in Malaysia is confusing, I’m posting it here just to help build our archive on the subject.  I think we are going to need it at some future time.

Apparently this recent complaint and appeal to Amnesty International is aimed at what the Rohingya leaders say is unfair treatment from the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.   It seems that UNHCR is telling the Rohingya to assimilate into mostly Muslim Malaysia or return to Burma.  If that is the policy of the UNHCR I commend it!

Persecution of Rohingya in Burma leads to Islamic terrorism?

I guess that is what the author is saying in this opinion piece from Sri Lanka’s Daily Mirror—that Muslims become radicalized due to persecution and poverty.

We have an entire category on the Rohingya—we have posted on this Muslim Burmese (Myanmar) minority group ever since we first heard that they were agitating for resettlement to the United States.  Some have already been resettled to Canada and to Norway (that we know of).

Opinion writer, Kusal Perera, gives a summary of how this group evolved from Arab traders in the 17th century to an aggrieved  Muslim fundamentalist group now spreading out throughout the world.  He says:

The plight of the Rohingya Muslims over the years has led to armed groups within the Rohingya society inside and outside Myanmar. By late 1980’s there were two very conspicuous armed groups, the Rohingya Solidarity Organisation (RSO) and the Arakan Rohingya Islamic Front (ARIF). These two organisations came together in 1996 to form the Rohingya National Alliance (RNA), while maintaining each others identities separately.

Today, the Rohingya Muslim Diaspora, especially those living as refugees, is viewed with suspicion in most countries. Muslim fundamentalism along with Al Qaeda (meaning “the base”) terrorism is being linked to most Rohingya Muslim groups in Bangladesh, Pakistan and even in some Mid East countries. According to an article published in February, 2006 by the Hudson Institute – Centre on Islam, Democracy and the future of the Muslim World – Rohingya Muslim settlements provide recruits for Harakat ul-Jihad Islami, a radical Islami armed group. The article explains that,

“In addition to minority flight, there have been other factors augmenting the relative power of the Islamists. Since 1991, perhaps as many as 300,000 Rohingya Muslims have entered Bangladesh across its South-Eastern border with Myanmar (Burma), a Jamaat-e-Islami stronghold. Many reside between the port city of Cox’s Bazaar and the Myanmar border. Jamaat-e-Islami and its student wing, the Islami Chatra League, have worked to radicalize these refugees, who are probably more susceptible to religious indoctrination after their persecution in Myanmar. Indeed, according to reports by human rights groups on local minorities, many of Harakat ul-Jihad Islami’s newest members are recruited from the Rohingya settlements.”

The author goes on to describe the lucrative arrangements some Rohingya have had when they signed on to fight in Afghanistan.   And, finally suggests that someone needs to pressure the Burmese junta to not persecute the Rohingya any more so they will not become radicalized fighters—seems that barn door is already open.

Thus allowing Myanmar to continue with its ruthless persecution of Rohingya Muslims has provided Muslim fundamentalism with ready recruits willing to fight anywhere for their conviction. Rohingya Muslims as radicalised Islam fundamentalists have basically become internationalised and they are not necessarily fighting for their right to be part of Myanmar society. Getting in contact with the Al-Qaeda doctrine and becoming a Islamic fundamentalist makes them all fight for a “liberated Islamic World Order” defeating American imperialism and Zionism, thus giving them a licence to fight without borders. That is again a fundamental difference between this brand of Islamic “terrorism” and those that fight for political rights within their own boundaries.

This mobility of the Rohingya cadres therefore, is one factor that could tie any country in the South and the South-East Asian region having a fractured and marginalised Muslim community to radicalised Islamism and then perhaps to Islamic guerrilla war.

This concept that persecution leads to radicalization and terrorism ignores the basic tenets of Islam which asks its adherents to spread the Islamic doctrine across the world.  It strikes me that this persecution issue is just an excuse.  One need only notice that the Burmese Karen Christians that we are resettling now by the tens of thousands in the US have not turned into terrorists due to their persecution by that same Burmese Junta.

One lobbying group advocating for the Rohingya is Refugees International headed by Ken Bacon with Farooq Kathwari as its chairman of the Board.

There have been hints that some Rohingya are already here intermingled with the Burmese Karen refugees being resettled throughout America, but no one is saying so officially.

Christian group wants “durable solution” for Rohingya Muslims

You would think there are plenty of Christians being persecuted around the world to keep these pressure groups busy for a long long time, but Christian Solidarity Worldwide is going to bat for the Rohingya Muslims of Burma.   We have an entire category about Rohingya because we have been following for sometime their lobbying campaign to be resettled in the West. 

Christian Solidarity Worldwide (CSW) just released this report from a whole 5 day trip to Bangladesh (below is from press coverage on that report):

New Delhi – Hundreds of Burmese Muslim minorities, seeking refuge on the Bangladesh-Burma border, are in dire straits, despite escaping brutal repression by the Burmese military junta, said a new report by the Christian Solidarity Worldwide.

The new report called “A people at the brink of extermination,” released yesterday, said Rohingya Muslims, who live in western Burma’s Arakan State are one of the minority groups that have suffered appalling oppression by the ruling junta.

The report quoted a Rohingya saying “The regime is trying to take away our identity. We will not be there in the very near future. Our prime concern is that we must not be eliminated …We are a people on the brink of extinction.”

The Rohingya are not going extinct.  They are spreading out throughout Bangladesh, Malaysia, Thailand, India, Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, New Zealand, China, Canada, Norway, and probably some are here in the US already.

CSW said:

“UNHCR and the Bangladesh government should try to find a durable solution to the problem,” said Roger, who was in the CSW team visiting the refugee camps.

When the phrase “durable solution” is used, that is UN code for resettle them in a town near you. 

Read our whole category on the strict Rohingya Muslims here.  In the very first post I did on this group I quoted both the Hudson Institute and Time (yes! Time) magazine on allegations that some members of this group are connected to Islamic terrorism.

Two Myanmar Muslim groups squabble over Rohingya?

This confusing story comes to us from a publication which I was glad to discover called The Muslim News.  You can read it and try to sort it out for yourselves, but the gist of it is that two Muslim organizations in the Arakan region of Myanmar (Burma) are fighting over who is most popular with the Rohingya.  Huh?

One organization alledgedly turned in the other for having a meeting at an unregistered location.

When Salim Ullah (U Than Htun), the Chairman of the district branch of the Myanmar Muslim Organization was hosting a meeting in an unrecognized office with some local people on March 30 and some other members were arrested from their homes on April 1 on allegation that they had connection with the meeting, he added.

The acquitted are Dr. Kamal alias Dr. Hla Myint son of Md Sayed of Ward No.4 of Maungdaw town and Dr. Zahir alias Dr. Zaw Nyint, a dentist. There are two categories of members —Township and District level. 

Some locals believe that Dr. Nurul Hoque alias Dr. Tun Aung, the Chairman of Township Islam Religion Council (IRC) of Burma complained to the authorities against the MMO. The two organizations (MMO and IRC) are into parallel work for the Rohingya community. Dr. Nurul Hoque does not want the MMO to be popular.

This article interested me on a bunch of levels.    First, note that everyone has an alias, what is up with that?  Is this standard practice in Burma?  Is this how unauthorized Muslims are getting into refugee camps throughout the region, by confusing the UN about who they are?

Then most everything I’ve read about the Rohingya Muslims is that they are persecuted and mostly out of Arakan and out of the country (living in squalor) looking for third country resettlement to the West (they want to live in a city near you).  Now here comes a story about how they are not only apparently still in Arakan in substantial numbers that they have at least these two competing organizations working for them. And, the ‘evil’ Burmese junta allows groups like these to operate, how repressive is that?

Are the Rohingya outside of Burma persecuted or simply economic migrants?  Economic migrants are not eligible for third country resettlement.

And, then my final question is why are these groups competing?  This is just a guess, but I’m wondering if one is a more radical Islamic group and the other less so.

Note to Rohingya readers:  Since we have heard from you before, maybe you could shed light on what the story is here with two competing Muslim groups?  Why are they fighting over which group will be the most “popular” with the Rohingya of Arakan?

See my original post on the Rohingya here.   And for more information, note we have a whole category called Rohingya Reports.

Rohingya in China: seeds of a durable solution?

Buried in this article * about human rights in China is a one line mention that things are going swimmingly with the Rohingya in China.  Do I see the telltale signs of a solution?

On a provincial level, there are some positive signs. Yunan province has accepted 20,000 Rohingya Muslims refugees, fleeing the persecution of the Burmese junta. The group has been well-treated and has become one of the most prosperous minority groups within China.

The Rohingya Muslims now spreading out throughout Thailand, Malaysia and Bangladesh are agitating to be resettled in the US.   They are already in Europe and Canada and some may already be here in the midst of the Burmese Karen Christians coming to the US by the thousands.   Note we have a whole category about their campaign to find a durable solution in third country resettlement here.

Since things are going so well in China’s Yunan province, then maybe that is the answer!  The UN can resettle them to China!

* What’s up with this?  The article was there but it has completely disappeared!